Hill Dissent Bypass Aedpa For Those Exempt From Execution
Seven experts. Seven opinions that all agree: Warren Lee Hill, Jr. is mentally retarded. Judge Barkett’s passionate dissent starts at a point the majority barely reached when they used procedural hurdles to deny Hill’s habeas petition – the fundamental proposition that Hill, per the Constitution, is exempt from execution. The crux of her argument is this: no statute, even one as strict as the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act (AEDPA), should trump the Constitution....