Drones are really having a moment these days, as everyone from backyard hobbyists to CEOs of major corporations have started to integrate drones into everyday life. However, the law surrounding the unmanned, hovering aircraft is still developing.

Think twice, then, before you send a drone out to collect evidence. A federal court in Connecticut ruled that stopping the use of a drone to record the site of a major auto accident does not violate First Amendment rights to free speech and the press.

Sorry Journalists, No Right to Film the Police

As for his First Amendment claims, the court found that there was no recognized right to record police activity. While other circuits have split on the issue – there is such a right in the First, Seventh, Ninth and Eleventh circuits – the Second has never addressed the question, meaning that there could be no clearly established right as needed for the officers to waive their qualified immunity.

The district court also went out of its way to note that, had Rivera even been in a jurisdiction which protected the right to film police activity, he may have fallen outside the scope of those protections. He wasn’t standing by with a camcorder, after all, but sending “a flying object into a police-restricted area … effectively trespassing onto an active crime scene.” Similarly, because there was no constitutional violation, the court dismissed Rivera’s retaliation complaint, as you cannot retaliate against the exercise of a right that doesn’t exist.

Call to Employer was Prior Restraint

It wasn’t all bad news for Rivera. Though the court dismissed almost all of his claims, it found that he had plead a sufficient case to show an unconstitutional prior restraint. The officer’s contact with Rivera’s employer, in which he threatened to withhold the “goodwill” of the department, operated as a restraint on his right to work as a member of the press.

Related Resources:

  • Connecticut Police say They Downed man’s Drone, not his Civil Rights (Reuters)
  • Drone Maker to Prevent Its Drones From Flying in D.C. (FindLaw’s Technologist)
  • Is It Legal to Videotape, Record Police? (FindLaw’s Blotter)
  • Drones Can Be Regulated by FAA Rules: NTSB (FindLaw’s Decided)

You Don’t Have To Solve This on Your Own – Get a Lawyer’s Help

Civil Rights

Block on Trump’s Asylum Ban Upheld by Supreme Court

Criminal

Judges Can Release Secret Grand Jury Records

Politicians Can’t Block Voters on Facebook, Court Rules