Former Virginia governor Bob McDonnell and his wife’s indictment was good reading, but the hilarity didn’t stop with the initial pleadings. Thanks to a recent spate of filings, some with little to no basis in existing laws, the judge in the case, U.S. District Judge James Spencer, asked the prosecutors and defense attorneys to limit their filings “for the sanctity of the trees.”

Judge Spencer also dismissed McDonell’s request to allow a related civil case to move forward, in hopes that evidence favorable to the defense would emerge, stating that the defense was “dancing through fantasyland,” reports The Washington Post.

Stay tuned folks. This is probably going to be one heck of a show.

Judge Spencer wasn’t convinced, first noting that he hadn’t ruled on the issue yet because he could not find case law “that came anywhere near it,” before pointing out that a different federal judge had already approved the prosecutors’ request to delay the civil trial.

Prosecutor Richard Cooke argued that not only could the defense talk to the potential witnesses in the civil case, but that the government had not encouraged them to withhold information from the McDonnells’ team. He also noted that the rules of evidence prohibit the defense from accessing forced civil depositions (which limits the utility of any civil trial). From the advisory committee notes to Federal Rule of Evidence 402:

Mixed Results for McDonnell

While the defense did have some of their requests granted, such as a subpoena for U.S. Food and Drug Administration and Securities and Exchange Commission records on Williams, the rest of the day was filled with bad news. Not only was their novel request from “fantasyland” denied, and the request for less paperwork made, but Judge Spencer also signaled that he didn’t see the case in the same light as the defense, calling it “not particularly complex.”

“For example, Rules 30(b) and 32(a)(3) of the Rules of Civil Procedure, by imposing requirements of notice and unavailability of the deponent, place limits on the use of relevant depositions. Similarly, Rule 15 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure restricts the use of depositions in criminal cases, even though relevant.”

The Post notes that the defense’s strategy is to portray the allegations against McDonnell as a novel stretching of federal law. “The defendants have been essentially operating on the assumption, and urging the court to operate on the assumption, that the government is going to do wrong,” Judge Spencer said. “I don’t make that assumption.”

Related Resources:

  • Massey Mine Explosion: Gary May Asks 4th Cir. to Vacate Sentence (FindLaw’s Fourth Circuit Blog)
  • Adios Judge Andre Davis; 2009 Obama Appointee Takes Senior Status (FindLaw’s Fourth Circuit Blog)
  • Brief Schedule Set for Va. Gay Marriage Appeal; Intervention Sought (FindLaw’s Fourth Circuit Blog)

You Don’t Have To Solve This on Your Own – Get a Lawyer’s Help

Civil Rights

Block on Trump’s Asylum Ban Upheld by Supreme Court

Criminal

Judges Can Release Secret Grand Jury Records

Politicians Can’t Block Voters on Facebook, Court Rules