Where to begin the story of Luke Brugnara, the former real estate mogul turned art con…

His criminal spiral downward began sometime in 2014. His sentence will not be over until about 2022. Perhaps the best place to start is in the middle of his case, when the judge granted him a furlough to meet with his attorneys at the courthouse.

Brugnara ran – literally. He fled on foot and evaded capture for several days. During the course of the trial, the judge held him in contempt dozens of times. It was a trial of the justice system as much as a trial of the defendant.

Judge, Jurors, and Nazis

Brugnara, 52 at the time of his sentencing in 2015, was once a real estate tycoon worth hundreds of millions of dollars due to some smart investments after the savings and loan crisis. But “Lucky Luke,” as he was known around San Francisco, ran out of luck when he tried to scam an art dealer.

On appeal to the Ninth Circuit, Brugnara blamed everybody in the courtroom – the judge, the attorneys, the jurors – for his conviction. Having represented himself for much of the proceedings, however, he had only himself to blame in the end.

“Every time the district court gave Brugnara any leeway, he took it and ran with it – literally, on one occasion,” the appeals court said. “He turned what should have been a regular fraud prosecution into a sideshow by upbraiding witnesses, disparaging the judge and government attorneys, and constantly violating basic rules of evidence and procedure, all the while feigning ignorance of proper conduct.”

If the drama weren’t high enough already, two jurors revealed that they had lied during voir dire about their own criminal convictions. One juror, during an inquiry by the judge, protested and brandished his shoe as if it were a weapon.

On appeal, Brugnara cited every irregularity in the proceedings. “But Brugnara’s bombastic journey through the courts ends here, because none of his arguments persuades us to reverse the jury’s verdict,” the court said.

Related Resources:

  • California Legal Research (FindLaw’s Cases & Codes)
  • Ninth Circuit Upholds Art Thief’s Seven-Year Sentence (Courthouse News)
  • Oakland Law Regulating Donation Bins Doesn’t Violate 1st Amendment (FindLaw’s U.S. Ninth Circuit Blog)

You Don’t Have To Solve This on Your Own – Get a Lawyer’s Help

Civil Rights

Block on Trump’s Asylum Ban Upheld by Supreme Court

Criminal

Judges Can Release Secret Grand Jury Records

Politicians Can’t Block Voters on Facebook, Court Rules